Read this quarter’s Intermedia here



Share this

By Bronwyn Howell and Roslyn Layton

In the last issue of Intermedia, Augusto Preta and Peng Peng reviewed the economic arguments for and against zero rating, or free data, noting that the practice of not counting some internet services in the mobile subscription could have some benefits, including lowering costs for consumers, increasing adoption of mobile broadband, allowing mobile operators to differentiate their services, and enhancing competition both among network and content providers. Despite this evidence, zero rating remains controversial and is subject to scrutiny under net neutrality rules. While some claim zero rating has nothing to do with net neutrality because there is no traffic management involved, others claim that it violates the net neutrality principle of treating all data the same.
The controversy is not likely to end soon. The courts of Netherlands and Slovenia, two countries with net neutrality laws since 2012, have ruled differently on the issue. While one zero rating offer may have been struck down in the Dutch court, four mobile operators successfully sued the Slovenian telecoms regulator Akos. The Slovenian court upheld the legality of a variety of zero-rated offers, saying that the country’s net neutrality law could not be interpreted to mean the prohibition of zero rating. The court cited the Slovenian Competition Authority’s pronouncement on zero rating, noting its competition-enhancing features and concluding that any determination about the practice should be made on the actual effects, rather than a presumption of harm.


As a complement to our article in the last issue, Bronwyn Howell and Roslyn Layton pose five key questions to assess each case for zero rating.

Intermedia Issue:
Vol 44, Issue 3
Issue Date:
October 2016
Competition Policy
Roslyn Layton Roslyn Layton PhD Fellow, Aalborg University, Denmark

Vol 44, Issue 3 Features

EDITORIAL 18.10.2016
Q&As with Takamiki Nishikawa, Juan Wilches and Syed Shah 18.10.2016
FREEDOM VS SECURITY 18.10.2016 Monroe E. Price
View All
Back to the top

The IIC is the world's only policy debating platform for the converged communications industry

We give innovators and regulators a forum in which to explore, debate and agree the best policies and regulatory frameworks for widest societal benefit.

Insight: Exchange: Influence

We give members a voice through conferences, symposiums and private meetings, as well as broad exposure of their differing viewpoints through articles, reports and interviews.

The new website will make it easier for you to gather fresh insights, exchange views with others and have a voice in the debate

Take a look Learn more about our updates
Please upgrade your browser

You are seeing this because you are using a browser that is not supported. The International Institute of Communications website is built using modern technology and standards. We recommend upgrading your browser with one of the following to properly view our website:

Windows Mac

Please note that this is not an exhaustive list of browsers. We also do not intend to recommend a particular manufacturer's browser over another's; only to suggest upgrading to a browser version that is compliant with current standards to give you the best and most secure browsing experience.