NEW IIC Podcasts – see more

BLOG

What ‘Death Cigarettes’ Teach Us About Facebook

17.04.2019
Share this

Tough regulation might benefit consumers. It will certainly benefit platforms.

‘I believe we need a more active role for governments and regulators.’ Thus wrote Mark Zuckerberg in his blog and Washington Post op-ed article. He goes on to identify four areas in which he says regulation is required (harmful content, protecting elections, privacy and data and data portability). Given the grilling that Facebook has suffered over the last 12 months as the platform most firmly in the firing line, it could be argued that his comments were merely an acceptance of the inevitable and that co-operation was not only a better look than opposition, but ‘engage and shape’ was a better strategy. However, it may be that Facebook has less to worry about than many people think.

For an instructive, if uncomfortable lesson, we can turn to the tobacco industry. Beginning in the 1960s, countries in the developed world progressively introduced policies designed to curb smoking. From health warnings, to advertising, then sponsorship and promotional bans, restrictions in distribution and at point of sale, plain packaging and punitive taxation, the result has been to create barriers to entry that have served to entrench the dominance of incumbents. ‘The Enlightened Tobacco Company’ was one challenger that dared to attempt market entry with the admirably honest ‘Death’ cigarettes, launched in 1991, and their brilliantly incisive light brand, ‘Slow Death’ (later re-branded, somewhat disappointingly, “Death Light”). By 1999, when the company finally gave up, the large tobacco companies had cemented their place as the darlings of investment managers, so reliable were their revenues and so cavernous their margins. Moreover, freed from having to invest in any marketing in developed countries, big tobacco was able to re-direct its efforts towards developing markets with entirely different cultural attitudes towards smoking. It’s taken the disruptive influence of “heat not burn” for them to feel any heat.

For the avoidance of doubt, the comparison drawn here between platforms and tobacco is not in terms of harm, but policy. Most agree that regulation is both inevitable and necessary, but the burden will always favour legacy participants with established market shares and deep pockets – you can be sure that the major platforms will argue strongly against any exemptions for smaller companies, especially now that the era of buying up their competition is over. The lesson from the tobacco industry is simply this: if you think the likes of Facebook, Twitter and Google are too powerful now, it might be that you haven’t seen nuthin’ yet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tough regulation might benefit consumers. It will certainly benefit platforms.

Theme:
Governance
Russell Seekins Russell Seekins Partner, Re:Strategy
You may also like... Blog
Africa needs investment in its cyber defences 09.07.2020
Blog
Comment: the EU General Court’s decision on Three-O2 deal 09.06.2020
Blog
Rumours of the death of the password are exaggerated, for now 02.06.2020

Latest

News
Improved satellite services in Africa 06.08.2020
News
Big Tech CEOs defend business practices in Congress Hearing 04.08.2020
Podcast
In Conversation: Ian Scott, CTRC and Chris Chapman, IIC 03.08.2020
News
5G investment accelerating throughout 2020 01.08.2020
View All
Back to the top

The IIC is the world's only policy debating platform for the converged communications industry

We give innovators and regulators a forum in which to explore, debate and agree the best policies and regulatory frameworks for widest societal benefit.

Insight: Exchange: Influence

We give members a voice through conferences, symposiums and private meetings, as well as broad exposure of their differing viewpoints through articles, reports and interviews.

The new website will make it easier for you to gather fresh insights, exchange views with others and have a voice in the debate

Take a look Learn more about our updates
Please upgrade your browser

You are seeing this because you are using a browser that is not supported. The International Institute of Communications website is built using modern technology and standards. We recommend upgrading your browser with one of the following to properly view our website:

Windows Mac

Please note that this is not an exhaustive list of browsers. We also do not intend to recommend a particular manufacturer's browser over another's; only to suggest upgrading to a browser version that is compliant with current standards to give you the best and most secure browsing experience.