Read this quarter’s Intermedia here

17th September 2024

IIC UK Chapter – Media plurality in an ad funded world?

Chapter Meetings

Date: Tuesday 17 September
Time: 17:00-19:00 BST, followed by a networking reception

Kindly hosted by Oxera

oxera logo

Discussion topics were:

  • Plurality: Impacts on news and media of shift to online advertising
  • Competition: What issues are emerging and what is CMAs view – see Privacy Sandbox , AdTech cases, DMCCA. And international cases.
  • Privacy: How can rights to privacy be protected and growth generated?

 

Registration Fees for delegates

Tuesday 17 September 2024
IIC UK Chapter Event

IIC Members – Free
Non-Members – £25 GBP (excluding VAT *) 
*VAT will be applicable for UK registrations only

If you feel the delegate fee may be a barrier to attending this event, please contact us at enquiries@iicom.org

 

We had a great host and scene setter from Oxera followed by a review of the market context from IIC UK Chair Tim Cowen. Tim referred to the issues identified in the Res Publica report, the Furman Report, Stigler Centre report that preceded the EU Digital Markets Act and the CMA’s 2020 Market Report on Online Markets and Digital Advertising. They identified the following issues:

  1. All digital markets exhibit high fixed cost low variable costs and high network externalities, meaning that increased returns to scale and scope and increased efficiency tends to generate monopolies. Like telecoms there is then a need to regulate to achieve public interest outcomes.
  2. Digital Advertising markets are largely now dominated by Facebook and Google each holding about a 40% share. The remainder is competed for by smaller publishers including newspapers. Incomes are reducing and threatening journalism. This has been called out in the Cairncross Review and the House of Lords report Breaking News? The EU has enacted the DMA and the UK has enacted the DMCC to intervene and secure public interest outcomes. So we have a problem of lack of funding for journalism and there isn’t a mechanism to ensure plurality of the media.
  3. We have moved from a world that is content supported by advertising to one where we have advertising supported by content. This means a world where people used to pay attention to content. They read content and were encouraged to apply their critical faculties and spend time understanding content and engaging with it.
  4. Advertising was in the past additional income for the distributor: newspapers and magazines were often sold in newsagents who generated income from the sale of sweets and tobacco as well as news and magazines.
  5. The shift in business model has affected the way news is consumed – lack of engagement is promoted by platforms that are promoting adverts being seen by consumers and paid for on a per impression or cost per click basis; this leads to and fuels doom scrolling.
  6. News and the public interest in plurality of the media is undermined. Essential elements of democracy are threatened.
  7. Platforms combining AI into their systems are accelerating the pace of consumption of copyrighted material that is used for their training data.
  8. The DMCC is designed to address market failure and provide a basis on which the DMU can take action to prevent loss of public goods such as plurality of the media.
  9. Ofcom has just launched a public service media review in which this will be discussed and the grounds for action consulted on.
  10. See further from one of our IIC members: Review of public service media: Ofcom publishes terms of reference – Wiggin LLP : Wiggin LLP

 

Speakers

Ali-Abbas Ali Director of Broadcasting Competition, Ofcom

Ali-Abbas Ali leads Ofcom’s work on Media Plurality and Competition. Over the last ten years he has worked across Ofcom’s competition portfolio, including Post, Telecoms as well as the Media sector. Prior to joining Ofcom he held senior finance posts at BT Group. His career also spans the motor industry, consulting and private equity.

Johan Keetelaar Senior Advisor, Oxera Consulting LLP

Johan Keetelaar joined Oxera in 2022, and is a member of its senior digital leadership team. He has spent most of his career working in the digital, telecoms and transport sectors, including more than 15 years as a strategic leader in competition and sector-specific regulation. More recently, he worked as a digital practitioner at Meta Inc.

Mr Keetelaar spent more than 15 years at the Authority for Consumers & Markets (the Dutch competition and regulatory authority), as well as one of its predecessors (OPTA) where he was Director Markets, Director of Transport, Telecoms and Post, and Director Competition. He was also a member of BEREC, the group of EU telecom and digital regulators.

Prior to joining Oxera, Mr Keetelaar was the Director of Economic Policy and Head of Connectivity and Access Policy in the EMEA region at Meta Inc. for four years.

Mr Keetelaar holds an MSc. in Econometrics from the University of Amsterdam.

Lynn Robinson Director General, International Institute of Communications

Lynn Robinson became Director General of the International Institute of Communications (IIC), in March 2020.

Lynn is an experienced senior director and trustee / non exec-director, having held key senior leadership positions in the technology, built environment, regulation, accreditation and dental industries. She has extensive experience of professional membership bodies working within the full spectrum including, Regulatory bodies, Industry associations and Chambers of Commerce. Lynn is a well-known and established ambassador in these areas having led on many strategic programmes to aid engagement, growth, retention, change management, stakeholder and political engagement.

An experienced Trustee / Non-Executive Director as Vice Chair at Arnos Vale Cemetery Trust, a unique heritage site in the heart of Bristol (UK), Lynn is also a Trustee / Non-Executive Director at The Bristol and Bath (UK), Parks Foundation.

Reflecting on becoming Director General at the IIC at the outbreak of a pandemic, Lynn said, ‘these last two years have been like no other we have known, with many challenges coming our way. In 2020 we successfully pivoted the organisation through a digital transformation programme to maintain a full schedule of events and by increasing the outputs delivered. Transforming the programme enabled us to continue to deliver the professional service and increase our engagement with IIC members and stakeholder community to remain connected to them through such a difficult time.

As we move through 2022, I am delighted to return to a combined in-person and online programme and to continue to evolve the IIC in to the next phase, with the vision and strategic focus to deliver our objectives and to build on our growth, engagement and retention’.

 

Sebastian Cuttill Parliamentary and Campaigns Manager, News Media Association (NMA)

Sebastian is the Parliamentary and Campaigns Manager at the News Media Association (NMA), the organisation representing over 800 national, regional and local news media publishers in the UK. The NMA has been highly engaged in the development of the new pro-competition regime for digital markets. Sebastian previously led the policy and public affairs work for the Professional Publishers Association, the UK trade association for specialist and magazine publishers. He has also worked on political campaigns and a devolution-focused advocacy group in the North of England.

Tim Cowen Partner, Preiskel & Co LLP

Chair of the Antitrust practice at Preiskel & Co LLP, Tim Cowen is independently recognised as one of the UK’s leading regulatory and competition lawyers focusing on the Technology Media and Tech sectors. He has vast experience of both in-house and private practice, having been a General Counsel at BT, a former Partner at Sidley Austin, and a member of the Competition Appeal Tribunal. He now specialises in complex second phase merger cases and competition cases in the courts.

Wednesday 16 October 2024

15:00-15:05 Welcome and Introductions

Lynn Robinson, Director General, International Institute of Communications

Jacquelynn Ruff, Consulting Counsel, Wiley Rein LLP, USA; Director, International Institute of Communications

 

15:05-15:30 Keynote

Moderator:
Jeff Gee
, Partner, Wilkinson Barker Knauer, LLP

Speaker:
Loyaan A. Egal, Chief, Enforcement Bureau, Federal Communications Commission, USA

15:30-17:00 International Perspectives on Stopping Spam and Scam Communications

Moderators:
Matthew Gerst, Partner, Wilkinson Barker Knauer, LLP

Ivana Kriznic, Head of Public Policy Canada, Latin America, Emerging Markets, Verizon Communications

Panelists:
Joshua Bercu, Executive Director, Industry Traceback Group (ITG)

Philippe Millet, Chairman, i3forum and The One Consortium Initiative

Jeremy Fenton, Executive Manager, Unsolicited Communications and Scams Branch, Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA)

Steven Harroun, Chief Compliance and Enforcement Officer, Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC)

Marina Gibbs, Director Policy, Networks & Communications Group, Ofcom

Johannes Vallesverd, Senior Advisor, Norwegian Communications Authority (Nkom)

Peter Moran, Senior Manager, Network Operations, Commission for Communications Regulation (ComReg), Ireland

 

17:00 Networking Reception
Download the agenda (PDF)
Event details
Date:
17th September 2024
Location:
London, United Kingdom
Region:
Europe
Chapter:
UK
Oxera Consulting LLP
200 Aldersgate St
Barbican
London
EC1A 4HD

Upcoming Events

View All
30th January 2025
IIC Legal Counsel Forum – AI for Regulators: Problem solver, or problem creator? Location: Virtual Core Event: Virtual Meetings
11th - 12th February 2025
Annual Asia Digital Communications and Media Forum 2025 Location: Seoul, South Korea Core Event: Digital Communications and Media Forum (DCMF)Regional Regulators Forum
  • Virtual Meetings
  • Digital Communications and Media Forum (DCMF)
Back to the top

The IIC is the world's only policy debating platform for the converged communications industry

We give innovators and regulators a forum in which to explore, debate and agree the best policies and regulatory frameworks for widest societal benefit.

Insight: Exchange: Influence

We give members a voice through conferences, symposiums and private meetings, as well as broad exposure of their differing viewpoints through articles, reports and interviews.

The new website will make it easier for you to gather fresh insights, exchange views with others and have a voice in the debate

Take a look Learn more about our updates
Please upgrade your browser

You are seeing this because you are using a browser that is not supported. The International Institute of Communications website is built using modern technology and standards. We recommend upgrading your browser with one of the following to properly view our website:

Windows Mac

Please note that this is not an exhaustive list of browsers. We also do not intend to recommend a particular manufacturer's browser over another's; only to suggest upgrading to a browser version that is compliant with current standards to give you the best and most secure browsing experience.